Skip to content
The Menzingers performing live in Knoxville, Tennessee
RIFFS · Album review

The Menzingers, Everything I Ever Saw: Twenty Years of Pub-Punk Nostalgia

Photo: Photo: AppalachianCentrist via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Scranton's dive-bar poets look back on album eight — then bring it to Roadrunner on November 21.

By Riff BostonNovember 19, 20262 min read

Same four guys, twenty years: Tom May and Greg Barnett on guitars and vocals, Eric Keen on bass, Joe Godino on drums. Everything I Ever Saw, their eighth album and latest for Epitaph, keeps the formula that made On the Impossible Past, Rented World and After the Party a generational run — beer-soaked singalongs about youth slipping away.

The drift toward Springsteen-style heartland rock continues, but the pub-punk core is intact.

Two frontmen, two views

The record's strength is its split perspective. May and Barnett come at middle age from different places, and trading songs gives the album range across the emotional spectrum.

Critics split, too. Kerrang! praised that spectrum; Pitchfork argued the lyrics lean on life lessons rather than the vivid scenes of old. Both are fair: a few choruses go broad, but the hooks are as crowdsurfable as ever.

Why to go

These songs were built for rooms that shout back. Roadrunner will.

The Menzingers at Roadrunner · Nov 21 — tickets
Riff Tunes

The Menzingers, Everything I Ever Saw

Essential tracks

Spotify
Find upcoming shows in Greater Boston →

Keep reading